Ex parte HIGUCHI et al. - Page 12




         Appeal No. 1999-1131                                                     
         Application No. 08/754,758                                               


         semiconductor devices; 2) second pins connected to signal                
         lines and not connected to one or more semiconductor devices;            
         and 3) wherein the first pins are provided on a first side,              
         the second pins are provided on a second side and the second             
         side is substantially perpendicular to the first side.                   
              Our review of the Michael prior art discloses that                  
         Michael's Figure 2 illustrates control signal pins, e.g., RAS,           
         CAS, WRITE and data-input/output pins, e.g., DI, DO.  However,           
         we do not find that the control and data pins of Michael are             
         respectively provided on sides that are "substantially"                  
         perpendicular to each other.                                             
              Turning to the Takeda prior art, we note that Takeda also           
         discloses control pins, e.g. WE, RAS, CAS, and data-                     
         input/output pins, e.g. DIN, DOUT.  However, as in Michael, we           
         find that the control and data pins of Takeda are not provided           
         on sides that are “substantially” perpendicular to each other.           
         In particular, Takeda's Figure 6 illustrates a configuration             
         that shows the WE control pin and the DIN, DOUT data-                    
         input/output pins on the same side.                                      
              Considering the Murai prior art, Murai’s Figure 2                   
         illustrates control (address) pins on one side and data pins             
                                        12                                        





Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007