Ex parte LEE - Page 10




          Appeal No. 1999-1796                                                         
          Application 08/705,149                                                       

          refresh test mode controller coupled to the interface for                    
          outputting internal test control signals in response to the                  
          self refresh test control signals during a self refresh test                 
          mode of the semiconductor device; self refresh circuitry                     
          coupled to the self refresh test mode controller for producing               
          refresh signals . . . in response to the internal test control               
          signals during the self refresh test mode . . ." (emphasis                   
          added).  Thus, claim 1 requires more than just monitoring the                
          refresh operation as taught by Kang.  Kang does not disclose                 
          that the refresh address test circuit 30 produces internal                   
          test control signals that are used to produce internal refresh               
          signals.  Thus, the rejection of claim 1, and its dependent                  
          claims 2-5 and 9-29, is reversed.                                            

               Claims 31-33                                                            
               Claim 31 recites "an interface allowing connection with                 
          an external device; . . . a self refresh test mode controller                
          . . . for receiving control signals from the interface and, in               
          response thereto, modifying performance of the semiconductor                 
          device while it's in the self refresh test mode" (emphasis                   
          added).  Thus, claim 31 requires more than just monitoring the               
          refresh operation as taught by Kang.  The refresh address test               
                                        - 10 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007