Appeal No. 1999-2284 Application 08/798,443 Yet another structural embodiment of the instant invention is recited by Appellants' independent claim 14, reproduced below: 14. In a magnetic disk drive comprising: a device enclosure having a bottom base and a cover; at least one storage disk; a spindle motor, coupled to and extending partially from the enclosure, the spindle motor having a shaft coupled to the disk for rotating the disk; a voice coil motor, coupled to the enclosure, for controlling the position of a carriage, the carriage supporting a magnetic head, the head being positioned relative to the disk for reading or writing magnetic information to and from the disk; a printed circuit board, coupled to the enclosure, for controlling the magnetic disk drive; and an interface cable connector, coupled to the printed circuit board, for providing a connection from a main CPU to the printed circuit board; wherein said printed circuit board is disposed outside the device enclosure at a position under the enclosure base, the printed circuit board being sized and shaped to cover a minority of a bottom surface of the enclosure case. In rejecting Appellants' claims, the Examiner relies on a single reference: Vettel et al. (Vettel) 5,038,239 Aug. 6, 1991 4Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007