Ex Parte MURRAY et al - Page 4




          Appeal No. 2001-0073                                                        
          Application 08/966,894                                                      

          rigid tube 62 corresponds to the claimed "connecting tube."  The            
          rigid tube 62 is coupled to the ink supply tube 60 via a seal 66            
          which overlaps the ends of tubing 62 and 110.  The rigid tube 62            
          fits through an aperture 27 in the top panel 26 (mislabeled as              
          126 in figure 1) of the cartridge and a lower end 61 is located             
          approximately at the bottom of the ink supply container 24, shown           
          more or less proximate to the print head 22.  In Erickson, the              
          rigid tube 62 is joined to the cartridge top 26 in an airtight              
          seal and includes appropriate strain relief (col. 8, lines 38-39;           
          col. 13, lines 5-7), such as by gluing the tubing to the                    
          aperture 27, thereby sealing the ink jet cartridge and providing            
          the appropriate strain relief (col. 8, lines 29-31; col. 13,                
          lines 21-23 & 29-32).                                                       
               The differences between Erickson and claim 22 are that                 
          Erickson does not disclose the claimed "first fitting integrally            
          molded into said top panel . . ." or the limitation beginning               
          with "a second fitting . . . ."  The difference between the                 
          cartridge in Erickson and claim 26 is that the interior of the              
          cartridge in Erickson is not "devoid of . . . ink supply tubing"            
          and Erickson does not disclose the limitation beginning with "a             
          luer-lock fitting molded into said top panel . . . ."                       
               McAffer discloses a transfer adaptor 21 for effecting fluid            
          communication, such as from an ampoule 61 to a vial 67 in                   
          figure 2.  The transfer adaptor 21 has a rigid cannula 23 with a            

                                        - 4 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007