HILL et al. V. ANDERSON et al. V. SNITZER et al. - Page 15





                72. Dr. Hill testified that Cooperman sent him a letter                             
          dated 12 May 1992 (HR 24)', advising Dr. Hill to send the                                 
          manuscript to the office of the Annual Review of Materials                                
          Science and not to the guest editors as they had initially                                
          requested (HR 9, $ 16).                                                                   
                73. The letter states that:                                                         
                I am aware that Dr. Laudise or Dr. Snitzer asked that the                           
                manuscript be sent to them directly but because all                                 
                production and editing emanates from this office, I request                         
                that you send your manuscript here. Please send two copies                          
                and I will forward one immediately to the senior editors.                           
                 (HR 24).                                                                           
                74. Hill's manuscript was received by the Annual Review of                          
          Materials Science on 8 September 1992 (Findings 49 and 54).                               
                75. Cooperman testified that the following procedures were                          
          followed in connection with the submission of manuscripts for                             
          Volume 23 of the Annual Review of Materials Science:                                      
                a) the guest editors for the Volume 23 were Robert A.                               
          Laudise and Elias Snitzer, whose responsibility was to find the                           
          best qualified authors to write on the keynote topic;                                     
                b) after the authors produced their manuscripts on the                              
          keynote topic, the manuscript was sent to the offices of the                              
          Annual Review of Materials Science;                                                       
                c) when the manuscript arrived at the Annual Review of                              
          Materials Science, it was immediately sent to all of the guest                            


                9 Snitzer moves to exclude the letter. For reasons given                            
          infra at 57, the letter is excluded.                                                      
                                               15                                                   







Page:  Previous  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007