HILL et al. V. ANDERSON et al. V. SNITZER et al. - Page 17





          59)                                                                                       
                80. Hill submits a comparison of the introduction to Volume                         
          23 with the introduction to Hill's manuscript (Hill Ex. 1058).                            
                81. The comparison shows similarities between the two                               
          introductions.                                                                            
                82. Although the insert prepared by Dr. Snitzer does not                            
          describe the elements of the count, it does describe generally                            
          the concept of writing gratings in optical fibers.                                        
                83. Cooperman testified that when a guest editor wrote an                           
          introduction that they would know what had been written:                                  

                Q And I think we saw in Volume 23 that there was an                                 
          introduction run by the guest editor.                                                     
                A That's correct.                                                                   
                Q That's something they can do also.                                                
                A Yes.                                                                              
                Q And sometimes guest editors read manuscripts.                                     
                A I'm sorry.                                                                        
                Q Sometimes guest editors read manuscripts.                                         
                A The guest editors receive copies of all of the                                    
          manuscripts for the keynote topic simply to read.                                         
                Q They are not asked to do the editing that the                                     
                A No, no. The point being that when they wrote the                                  
          introduction, they would know what had been written; and if they                          
          wanted to talk about a specific manuscript, they could. (HR 265,                          


                                                17                                                  







Page:  Previous  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007