Ex Parte SHAIO et al - Page 7



          Appeal No. 1999-2380                                                        
          Application No. 08/575,743                                 Page 7           


          secured, unsecured source/destination or uncertain of the                   
          association," and that (id.) "the prior art cited above teaches             
          the ability to at least recognize the association with a secured            
          or unsecured destination.  The appellant's claims need to                   
          specifically recite the requirement for determining whether all             
          three states can be detected in order for this argument to be               
          overcome."                                                                  
               Appellants assert (brief, page 9) that claim 1 requires                
          consideration of all three states in the processing of data                 
          packets.                                                                    
               Claim 1 recites that:                                                  
               determining within a first degree of certainty whether                 
               a source address of one said executable packet is                      
               associated with anyone of said plurality of secured                    
               computers,                                                             
               said source address is not associated with anyone                      
               of said plurality of secured computers,                                
               or association of said source address with anyone                      
               of said plurality of secured computers is uncertain; and               
               We observe that claim 1 also contains similar language with            
          respect to a destination address.  From the recited language, we            
          find that claim 1 requires determining whether a source address             







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007