CHEN et al. v BOUCHARD et al. - Page 111



          Interference No. 103,675                                                      

    and included them in her Fourth Quarter Report (CX 247). Dr. Golik                  
    also reported the results in his quarterly report to Drs. Farina and                
    Vayas in November 1991 (CX 88).                                                     
              The work allegedly performed by Dr. Chen in August 1992 is                
    entirely uncorroborated. Further, all the work of Drs. Golik and Gao                
    "confirming" the identity of the samples allegedly prepared by Dr.                  
    Chen was based entirely on information Dr. Chen provided them with                  
    respect to the compounds structure and identity. Thus, none                         
    of the testimony by Drs. Golik and Gao or their work "identifying" the              
    samples given to them by Dr. Chen can be considered to be                           
    corroboration independent of the inventors.                                         
                                  BMS-182902-01                                         
              In November 1991, Dr. Kant, at the request of Dr. Chen,                   
    attached the Taxotere side-chain to the mixture of the 7-fluoro                     
    epimers of baccatin III he had prepared and recorded in his notebook                
    number 32242. Dr. Kant recorded the procedure he used to prepare the                
    compounds in his laboratory notebook (CX 38; CX 39). Dr. Kant signed                
    his notebook pages in April 1994. Under the heading "WITNESSED AND                  
    UNDERSTOOD BY" at the bottom right hand side of the notebook page                   
    there is an illegible signature and a date which appears to be either               
    April ("4") or September ("9") 1994. As with all Chen et al.'s                      
    proffered notebook pages, the witness of Dr. Kant's notebook pages has              
                                       111                                              


Page:  Previous  104  105  106  107  108  109  110  111  112  113  114  115  116  117  118  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007