ROSENTHAL v. MAGEE - Page 55




              Interference No. 104,403                                                                                     

                                                 Conclusion                                                                
                        We have examined the evidence submitted by the junior party                                        
                 and considered the arguments made by the junior party regarding                                           
                 priority of invention.  While we hold that the junior party actually reduced                              
                 the invention of the count to practice on August 14, 1992, we also hold                                   
                 that the junior party is not entitled to rely on this reduction to practice                               
                 because he suppressed or concealed the invention.  We also conclude                                       
                 that the junior party has failed to prove that the senior party derived the                               
                 invention of the count or was involved in inequitable conduct.                                            
                                            Motions to suppress                                                            
                        The senior party has filed a motion to suppress various parts of                                   
                 the Rosenthal record.  We have determined that even when all the                                          
                 evidence the junior party has submitted into evidence has been                                            
                 considered, the junior party has failed to prove priority of invention.                                   
                 We, therefore,  find in it unnecessary to consider this motion.                                           












                                                      55                                                                   





Page:  Previous  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  51  52  53  54  55  56  57  58  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007