NICHOLS et al. V. TABAKOFF et al. - Page 25





          Interference No. 104,522 Paper108                                                       
          Nichols v. Tabakoff Page 25                                                             
                1994, are attached as Exhibit 2039 and Exhibit 2038, respectively. The            
                mass spectral data indicates that the expected product having a 4                 
                diphenyl urea substitution ((NN-diphenyl)-4-ureido-5,7-dichloro-2                 
                carboxy-quinoline ethyl ester) was successfully produced.                         

                On August 12, 1994, 1 sent 10 mg of 94B-32-111 ((NN-diphenyl)-4-ureido            
                5,7-dichloro-2-carboxy-quinoline ethyl ester) to Snell for pharmacological        
                testing and 280 mg to NIH (NIH # 236075) for anticonvulsant testing (see          
                page 94B-32 from Exhibit 2024). Snell references this compound in his             
                email addressed to me dated July 10, 1996, previously filed as Exhibit            
                2026. A copy of the NIH registration record for sample 94B-32-111 is              
                attached as Exhibit 2040 to the declaration of James P. Stables (Exhibit          
                2035). The NIH registration record for sample 94B-32-111 (Exhibit 2040)           
                includes the date the compound was shipped to NIH (August 12, 1994)               
                and processed by NIH (August 30, 1994) and the chemical structure of              
                the 4-diphenyl urea derivative.                                                   
                [NR, p. 33, T7 36-38.] [See also NR, p. 14, 1145-46.]                             

          55. Notebook Ex 2024 is a two page document that has no notebook identifying            

          number on either page, is improperly dated (year missing), is not signed and is not     
          witnessed.                                                                              

          56. The second page of Ex 2024 contains an entry, reading in relevant part, "8/4        

          have NMR that seems to fit ...8/12 mass spectrum: 479 & 481 got great mass                  

          spectrum." No copy of the NMR spectral data (authenticated or not) referred to in Ex    

          2024 is of record.                                                                      

          57. William E. Seifert, Jr., Ph.D., testified that he performed a FAB mass spectrum     

          on a sample designated 94B-32-111 provided by Dr. Nichols (NR, p. 241, 14).9            

          58. The FAB mass spectral data obtained for 94B-32-111 is shown in Ex 2039.             




                9 Citations to the testimony of Dr. Seifert are to Nichols Record (NR) pages because Nichols did
          not submit a copy of the November 19, 2001 Oral Deposition of Dr. Seifert as an exhibit. We note that NR
          p. 241 corresponds to Ex 2038.                                                          







Page:  Previous  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007