Ex Parte MOLDENHAUER et al - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2002-1875                                                        
          Application 09/245,776                                                      

          computer hardware resource with a corresponding real office                 
          device, the computer resource enabling the computer to function             
          like the consumer device (col. 2, lines 63-57).  For example, the           
          image of Fig. 7A resembles a speakerphone/answering machine.                
          Taylor is controlling computer functions, not actual external               
          office devices.                                                             

                    Claims 9 and 21                                                   
               Initially, we interpret claim 9 to correspond to the                   
          description at page 5, lines 12-18 and page 16, line 8, to                  
          page 17, line 2 of the specification.  Technical assistance is              
          shown in Fig. 8d.  The "query for a model of a set-top box for              
          which the user needs assistance" is interpreted to correspond to            
          dialog "Choose a receiver to begin troubleshooting" in dialog               
          bubble 834, where the "set-top box" refers to one of the                    
          receivers shown at 836; although this is really a declarative               
          statement rather than an interrogatory (query) statement, the               
          specification states (page 16, line 9) that user is asked to                
          choose a particular receiver and the original claim recites a               
          "query."  The "displaying the set-top box selected in response              
          to (a)" is interpreted to correspond to the illustration of the             
          selected receiver 846 and its remote control 848 (specification,            
          page 16, lines 20-21; Fig. 8f), although it is not in direct                
          response to selection of the receiver.  The "means for                      
          interrogating the display of said selected set-top box" is                  
                                        - 6 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007