Ex Parte Goldstein - Page 12



           Appeal No. 2005-0823                                                                        
           Application No. 10/300,895                                             Page 12              


            reporting and does not disclose or suggest anything other than                             
            weekly reporting.  With respect to Brice, appellant asserts (id.)                          
            that although Brice discloses an accounting system that can                                
            generate reports, it does not suggest that the reports have                                
            anything to do with CRS, and (brief, page 15) that nothing in                              
            Brice suggests that the reports serve any function other than                              
            internal management.  Appellant adds that Brice does not teach                             
            running daily reports because customized reports are not daily                             
            reports.  Turning to IATA, appellant asserts (brief, page 16)                              
            that the IATA article expressly states that ARC had no plans to                            
            move to daily reporting, and that daily reporting would only                               
            occur if IATA consolidated its Billing and Settlement Plans                                
            (BSPs) and chose ARC to run its operations.                                                
                  It is further argued (brief, page 17) that not only is there                         
            no motivation for combining IAH with Brice, but that IATA teaches                          
            away from being combined with IAH and Brice because there is no                            
            reason to combine a reference related to reporting ticket                                  
            instances with one for back-office internal reporting.  Appellant                          
            adds (brief, page 18) that there were no plans to move away from                           
            weekly reporting.  It is further asserted (id.) that the                                   
            statements in IATA are double and triple hearsay.                                          






Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007