Ex Parte Goldstein - Page 14



           Appeal No. 2005-0823                                                                        
           Application No. 10/300,895                                             Page 14              


            combination set forth in the claim, including 'reporting the                               
            issuance of the travel ticket externally and by the following day                          
            after the issuance of the travel ticket" as recited in claim 1,                            
            or as substantially recited in each of the independent claims.                             

            From our review of appellant's specification, we note that the                             
            specification, including the originally filed claims, does not                             
            specifically recite that the reporting is done by the following                            
            day.  However, from the disclosure (specification, page 7) that                            
            “[a]fter recording the transaction (Step S5) periodic sales                                
            reporting is performed electronically or manually.  (Step S11)                             
            For example, but not by way of limitation, the sales may be                                
            reported elecronically or manually and the period of reporting                             
            may be fixed (e.g., hourly or daily) or variable (e.g., random,                            
            or otherwise” (underlining added).  We find that the "e.g.,                                
            hourly or daily" language of the specification provides basis for                          
            the language "by the following day."  From the disclosure of, for                          
            example, daily reporting, we find that daily reporting, in                                 
            contrast to weekly reporting that was done in the past, provides                           
            a suggestion of reporting the following day.                                               







Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007