Ex Parte Goldstein - Page 16



           Appeal No. 2005-0823                                                                        
           Application No. 10/300,895                                             Page 16              


                        "Your daily ticket sales are transmitted from your                             
                  reservation system(s) to IAR nightly so that you can                                 
                  view and reconcile your report the following day.  IAR                               
                  collects the data and electronically prepares your                                   
                  weekly ARC Sales Report on a daily basis.  IAR will                                  
                  verify each transaction, as it is received, identify                                 
                  specific errors, and allow you to make corrections                                   
                  prior to the Sales Report submission deadline of                                     
                  Tuesday midnight Eastern Time" (page 2, left column).                                
                        "Although a back office accounting system is not                               
                  necessary to use IAR, an optional tool is available so                               
                  that IAR can send the ticket information to your back                                
                  office system using an Internet file" (page 2, right                                 
                  column).                                                                             
                        "It is recommended that voids be processed in your                             
                  GDS/CRS whenever possible.  However, in IAR you have                                 
                  the ability to void sales" (page 5, left column).                                    
                        "Your client’s account is charged if you void                                  
                  after midnight the day of sale.  You have until Monday                               
                  midnight following the close of the sales week to use                                
                  the void format in your GDS/CRS.  A credit reversal is                               
                  sent to the credit card contractor and the void appears                              
                  on your IAR report the next day" (page 5, left column).                              
                        "In IAR you may recall and make changes to an                                  
                  already submitted report up until the deadline time and                              
                  date (Tuesday midnight Eastern time)" (page 6, left                                  
                  column).                                                                             
            From the disclosure of IAH, we find that the reference teaches                             
            all of the limitations of independent claim 1, with the exception                          
            of reporting the issuance of the ticket by the following day.                              
            Although the examiner takes the position (answer, pages 4 and 6)                           
            that IAH imposes a fee for changes made after the issuance has                             






Page:  Previous  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007