Ex Parte Beutler et al - Page 4


              Appeal No. 2006-0227                                                                   Page 4                 
              Application No. 10/121,264                                                                                    

              containing” “a substance onto or into which genetic material may be deposited, which                          
              can transport the genetic material when the [substance] is moved,” where the region                           
              also contains a “layer comprising” “a substance onto or into which genetic material may                       
              be deposited, which can transport the genetic material when the [substance] is moved.”                        
                     In addition, the layer comprising a substance that can transport the genetic                           
              material when the substance is moved has deposited on or in it genomic DNA                                    
              comprising more than one chromosome from a “vertebrate, invertebrate, plant, and                              
              prokaryotic” individual that belongs to “any group of individuals.”                                           
                     When we give the terms of claim 23 their broadest reasonable interpretation                            
              consistent with the definitions in the specification, we interpret claim 23 to be directed to                 
              a device comprising an object that includes a region having a layer of a substance that                       
              can transport genetic material when the substance is moved, and that has deposited on                         
              or in it at least two chromosomes from the genomic DNA of any organism.                                       
                     Claim 24 is directed to the same device, wherein the layer of a substance that                         
              can transport genetic material when the substance is moved comprises “a saccharide                            
              selected from at least one of sucrose and glucose.”  (Although the preamble of claim 24                       
              recites the “substrate of claim 23,” we interpret the claim as being directed to the device                   
              defined by claim 23; a dependent claim must incorporate all of the limitations of the                         
              claim from which it depends.  35 U.S.C. § 112, fourth paragraph.)                                             
                     Claim 40 is directed to a device comprising “an object onto which genetic                              
              material may be deposited,” and a “layer comprising” “a substance onto or into which                          
              genetic material may be deposited, which can transport the genetic material when the                          
              [substance] is moved,” where the layer comprises two separate positions at which there                        





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007