Ex Parte Mitra et al - Page 7




         Appeal No. 2006-1729                                                       
         Application No. 10/107,628                                                 

                   [P]roviding a compactor characterized by a binary                
                   matrix having a row for each of a plurality of circuit           
                   elements and a column for each compactor output.                 


              We also note that claim 22 reads in part as follows:                  
                   [A]t least one exclusive OR gate coupled between each            
                   input and at least one output; and each input being              
                   coupled to said outputs differently.                             
         At page 4, lines 12 through 18, Appellants’ specification states:          
                        A compactor design can be represented as a binary           
                   matrix (matrix with only zeros and ones) with n rows             
                   and m columns.  Each row corresponds to a scan chain             
                   and each column corresponds to a compactor output.  The          
                   entry in row i and column j of the binary matrix is 1,           
                   if the ith scan chain output is exclusive OR-ed to               
                   generate the jth output of the compactor; the matrix             
                   entry is 0 otherwise.                                            
         Further, at page 5, lines 17 through 20, Appellants’                       
         specification states:                                                      
                        As shown in FIG. 2, the exclusive OR gates 14 are           
                   arranged such that there is at least one exclusive OR            
                   gate 14 coupled between each input to the compactor 12a          
                   and at least one output from the compactor.  Each input          
                   is also coupled to the outputs differently in                    
                   accordance with one embodiment of the present                    
                   invention.                                                       
              Thus, representative claim 1 does require a compactor                 
         characterized by matrix having a row for each of the plurality of          
         circuit elements and a column for each of the plurality of                 
         outputs.  Similarly, representative claim 22 does require an Ex-           



                                         7                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007