Ex Parte Ravichandran - Page 9



         Appeal No. 2006-2441                                                       
         Application No. 10/056,224                                                 

                   temporal identifier signal and the probe signals in              
                   memory.                                                          
         We note that at pages 4 and 5, paragraphs 17 and 18, Appellant’s           
         specification states the following:                                        
                   0017] The performance monitor circuit 112 provides the           
              capability of collecting probe data signals and associating           
              a temporal identifier, such as a time stamp, to the probe             
              data signals. (Emphasis added).                                       
                   [0018] FIG. 2 illustrates the probe signals in an                
              embodiment of the present invention. The performance monitor          
              circuit 112 can receive three signals: (1) a first signal 134         
              indicating the value of a program counter (PC); (2) a second          
              signal 136 indicating a device identifier; and (3) a third            
              signal 138 representing the number of misses that the                 
              identified device has incurred thus far. The performance              
              monitor circuit 112 associates a time stamp signal 132 with           
              these signals and stores their values in the second memory            
              110. Preferably, the second memory 110 is used to store data          
              from the performance monitor circuit 112 only. The time stamp         
              signal 132 can be 16 bits wide, the program counter signal 134        
              can be 32 bits wide, the miss identifier signal 136 can be 4          
              bits wide, and the miss counter signal 138 can be 16 bits wide        
              as shown in FIG. 2. The signals show in FIG. 2 are herein             
              referred to as the probe data or probe data signals.                  
              Thus, the claim does require generating a temporal identifier         
         for association with a probe signal, and subsequently storing the          
         probe signals with associated temporal identifiers.                        
              Now, the question before us is what Bunnell and Roeber would          
         have taught to one of ordinary skill in the art?  To answer this           
         question, we find the following facts:                                     


                                         9                                          




Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007