Ex Parte Ravichandran - Page 11



         Appeal No. 2006-2441                                                       
         Application No. 10/056,224                                                 

              memory resident on the control card is used to collect event          
              records from the target processor(s) for transfer to one or           
              more host systems for post processing of event data. The              
              control card includes a network interface to facilitate               
              communication between the host computer(s) used for post              
              processing of event data and to control, communicate with             
              and access the control card.                                          
              With the above discussion in mind, we find that the                   
         combination of Bunnell and Roeber does not teach the claimed               
         invention.  We find that Bunnell teaches a device for monitoring           
         CPU accesses to the main memory (22).  Particularly, Bunnell               
         teaches a CPU (28) and a cache memory (30) connected to a CPU              
         activity monitor (24) via a cache miss signal (36). Whenever the           
         CPU requests data, the cache memory checks its internal memory             
         for the requested data.  If the data is not available in the               
         cache, it issues a miss signal, and the CPU accesses the main              
         memory for the requested data.  Bunnell also teaches that the CPU          
         activity monitor receives a clock signal, a cache miss signal and          
         a plurality of modes signals to determine when the CPU                     
         transitions from an active to an inactive state and vice-versa.            
         Next, we find that Roeber teaches an event logging mechanism               
         having a central memory for storing user-designated events data            
         and time-stamps associated therewith.  It is our view that one of          
         ordinary skill in the art would have duly realized that Roeber’s           

                                         11                                         




Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007