Ex Parte Renault - Page 6

                  Appeal 2006-3219                                                                                              
                  Application 10/122,270                                                                                        

                          The language of claim 14 specifies, in product-by-process format, any                                 
                  automotive part that can be obtained by molding from a plurality of any                                       
                  manner of blanks, including any length, width and depth, that include at least                                
                  two layers of blanks, each of the layers having any manner of woven mat                                       
                  made of tows that contain any manner of fibers commingled with any                                            
                  manner and amount of thermoplastic resin material, regardless of the manner                                   
                  in which the part is molded or otherwise prepared from the blanks.  See                                       
                  generally, In re Thorpe, 777 F.2d 695, 697, 227 USPQ 964, 966 (Fed. Cir.                                      
                  1985).                                                                                                        
                          The claimed part comprises at least any manner of central shock-                                      
                  absorbing portion.  The part further “is adapted” in any manner to be                                         
                  attached to an automotive vehicle through any manner of a pair of                                             
                  attachment locations spaced apart a predetermined distance of any length,                                     
                  however short, and either horizontally or vertically.  Indeed, in the body of                                 
                  the claim, the part further comprises at least the said spaced apart pair of                                  
                  attachment locations as “portions” further having fixation points or holes                                    
                  and connected to the central shock-absorbing portion.                                                         
                          The part still further comprises at least any manner of two                                           
                  thermoplastic reinforced fiber “structures,” each formed by any manner of                                     
                  “woven mats” made of tows that contain any manner of woven fibers wetted                                      
                  by said any manner of thermoplastic resin material.  The “woven mats,” and                                    
                  thus, the “structures,” “at least partially forms to any extent the central                                   
                  shock-absorbing portion and the pair of attachment portions, and                                              
                  continuously extends between the attachment portions to link the attachment                                   
                  portions.”  The “woven mats” can be the same “woven mats” forming the                                         


                                                               6                                                                

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013