Ex Parte Miller et al - Page 5

                Appeal 2007-0123                                                                                 
                Application 10/408,939                                                                           
                          filler, and 10-80% melting point component.  (Col. 6, l. 61-col. 7, l.                 
                          1).                                                                                    
                       10) McCullough discloses a thermally conductive composite                                 
                          material that is easily moldable or castable.  (Col. 1, ll. 6-8).                      
                       11) McCullough discloses using a first thermally conductive                               
                          filler having a relatively high aspect ratio of at least 10:1 and a                    
                          second thermally conductive filler having a relatively low aspect                      
                          ratio of 5:1 or less, in amounts of 25 to 60 vol. % and 10 to 25 vol.                  
                          %, respectively.  (Col. 2, ll. 25-30).                                                 
                       12) According to McCullough, the low aspect ratio filler fills the                        
                          voids between the high aspect ratio filler.  As a result, the number                   
                          of interfaces and base matrix thickness between filler members is                      
                          reduced, thereby providing a thermally composite material having                       
                          improved thermal conductivity and performance.  (Col. 2, ll. 36-                       
                          42).                                                                                   
                       13) McCullough “preserves the advantages of prior art thermally                           
                          conductive plastic compositions” (col. 2, ll. 9-10), which include                     
                          “a polymer base matrix loaded with a granular material, such as                        
                          boron nitride” (col. 1, ll. 38-39), and exemplifies the same (see,                     
                          e.g., Fig. 1, col. 3, ll. 1-3 and col. 3, l. 38 – col. 4, l. 6).                       
                       14) McCullough discloses an example in which the high aspect                              
                          ratio filler is carbon flakes with an independent thermal                              
                          conductivity of 800 W/m-ēK and the low aspect ratio filler is boron                    
                          nitride granules with an independent thermal conductivity of 400                       
                          W/m-ēK (col. 5, l. 65 –col. 6, l. 5).                                                  



                                                       5                                                         

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013