Ex Parte Karwowski et al - Page 5

                Appeal 2007-0726                                                                                
                Application 10/264,561                                                                          
                          starch is mentioned as a preferred pregelatinized starch.  (Lanner,                   
                          col. 6, ll. 15-28).                                                                   
                       4. Lanner does not specifically disclose the use of an unmodified                        
                          pregelatinized waxy starch or a raw potato starch in the dry                          
                          mixture (Lanner in its entirety).                                                     
                       5. The dry mixture of Lanner may further contain seasoning,                              
                          flavoring, leavening agents, and other additives such as other fine                   
                          particulates that can adhere to the edible cores during the coating                   
                          process (Lanner, col. 6, ll. 24-28).                                                  
                       6. Raw potato starch and unmodified pregelatinized waxy starch were                      
                          known ingredients for use in dry flour/starch-based mixtures for                      
                          food coatings (Appellants’ admission, Reply Br. 5; Chino, col. 2,                     
                          ll. 19-22, Example 5; Mochizuki, col. 1, ll. 24-34 and col. 2, ll. 16-                
                          40).                                                                                  
                       7. Chino provides several examples of useful flours and starches for                     
                          use in a dry mixture including cereal flours such as wheat flour and                  
                          rice flour and such starches as alpha waxy maize starch, or corn                      
                          starch (Chino, col. 2, ll. 19-22; Example 5).                                         
                       8. Chino also recognizes that wheat flour and raw potato starch are                      
                          non-expandable and that the ratio of non-expandable flours or                         
                          starches to expandable flours or starches determines whether                          
                          leavening agent is required (Chino, col. 2, ll. 26-42).  “Potato                      
                          starch” as used by Chino refers to potato starch in its raw form                      
                          based upon the specific terminology used in the art (Answer 8).  If                   
                          the starch is modified, it is labeled “modified” and if the starch is                 
                          cooked, it is labeled “pregelatinized.” (id.).                                        

                                                       5                                                        

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013