Ex Parte Armijo et al - Page 4

                Appeal 2007-1096                                                                              
                Application 10/872,181                                                                        

                the Specification to be a structure which is capable of covering a part of the                
                uvula or soft palate, and to be compressed against it.                                        
                      The “backing” member is for attaching the “at least one piercing post”                  
                to the uvula and soft palate.  The claim requires that it keep the stiffening                 
                member “in place” and provide “a predetermined pressing force of said                         
                stiffening member to the uvula and the soft palate.”  The Specification states                
                that the “pressing force” is to compress the stiffening member against the                    
                uvula and/or soft palate in order to inhibit the uvula and soft palate fluttering             
                (id. at 6: 8-12 and 24-30) that causes snoring.  Thus, we interpret the                       
                “pressing force” to be a force which is sufficient to compress the stiffening                 
                member against the uvula or soft.                                                             

                                             THE PRIOR ART                                                    
                      Nelson describes systems and methods “for moving and/or restraining                     
                tissue in the upper respiratory system . . . for the treatment of . . . snoring . . .         
                and obstructive sleep apnea.”  (Nelson, col. 1, ll. 8-12.)                                    
                      The system employs at least one primary magnet 36 and at least                          
                      one secondary magnet 38. Together, the magnets 36 and 38                                
                      serve to position, stabilize and maintain a preferred orientation                       
                      of tissue in an oral cavity and airway in both humans and                               
                      animals. By moving and stabilizing tissue in a desired location                         
                      and shape, the system mediates or prevents the obstruction of                           
                      the upper airway that results in sleep-related breathing                                
                      disorders.                                                                              
                (Id. at col. 6, ll. 58-65).                                                                   





                                                      4                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013