Ex Parte Mihalos et al - Page 5

                    Appeal 2007-1390                                                                                                       
                    Application 10/842,392                                                                                                 

                    AFFIRM the sole ground of rejection in this appeal essentially for the                                                 
                    reasons stated in the Answer, as well as those reasons set forth below.1                                               
                                                              OPINION                                                                      
                            We determine the following factual findings from the record in this                                            
                    appeal:                                                                                                                
                            (1) Morano discloses an edible, bakable filling with low Aw that can                                           
                                 be used for making multi-layered food compositions where the                                              
                                 outer layers are a bakery dough, and the co-extruded or co-                                               
                                 laminated product has a long shelf life (Abstract; col. 1, ll. 13-14,                                     
                                 27-29, and 45-47; col. 4, ll. 6-13);                                                                      
                            (2) Morano teaches that the edible filling composition includes a                                              
                                 hydrophilic liquid phase, an edible solids phase, and small                                               
                                 amounts of a fat/oil phase, including an example to a low-fat,                                            
                                 cheese-flavored filling (col. 3, ll. 44-51; col. 4, ll. 25-27; col. 10,                                   
                                 ll. 30-42 and 51-52; col. 11, ll. 15-18; and col. 12, ll. 8-10);                                          
                            (3) Morano teaches that the edible filling is “particularly useful” in the                                     
                                 production of filled bakery products such as crackers, and the                                            
                                 method of preparation involves filling or otherwise combining an                                          
                                 uncooked dough with the thermostable filling and then cooking                                             
                                 the combination (col. 3, ll. 52-55; and col. 3, l. 67-col. 4, l. 3);                                      
                            (4) Thulin discloses a method of continuously forming individual                                               
                                 product pieces having a filler therein, where a first flat dough sheet                                    
                                 is provided, a natural/artificial filler is periodically deposited on                                     
                                 this first sheet, then the first sheet with filler is enclosed by a                                       
                                                                                                                                          
                    1 We note that we have also considered related US Patents Nos. 6,863,911;                                              
                    6,905,719; and 6,905,720 (see the Specification, ¶ [0001]).                                                            
                                                                    5                                                                      

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013