Ex Parte Keller - Page 2

                Appeal 2007-2608                                                                              
                Application 10/473,998                                                                        

                                               DISCUSSION                                                     
                      The Specification describes “[a] system of intervertebral disc                          
                prostheses . . . which includes standard prostheses and corrective prostheses”                
                (Spec. ¶ 41), wherein “the centre of articulation of a [corrective] prosthesis                
                relative to the vertebral body . . . is offset ventrodorsally compared to the                 
                standard prostheses” (id. at ¶ 5).                                                            
                      As explained in more detail in the Specification,                                       
                      [i]t is known to replace damaged intervertebral discs with                              
                      prostheses which consist of two cover plates, each to be                                
                      connected to an adjacent vertebral body, and a prosthesis core,                         
                      said prosthesis core cooperating with one or both cover plates                          
                      via complementary spherical surfaces of articulation . . . The                          
                      cover plates have contact surfaces by means of which they are                           
                      connected to the adjacent vertebral bodies . . . the centre of                          
                      articulation of the prostheses [is] arranged in such a way that                         
                      the movements permitted by the prosthesis are as far as possible                        
                      identical to the natural ones and that forces can be transmitted                        
                      uniformly between the vertebral bodies and the prosthesis. . . .                        
                      this objective is approached by arranging the centre of                                 
                      articulation in a predetermined spatial relationship to the                             
                      contact surfaces of the cover plates and by providing the cover                         
                      plates with an edge which bears on the ventral margin of the                            
                      associated vertebral body and thereby determines the relative                           
                      position of the cover plate to the vertebral body . . .                                 
                (Spec. ¶ 1).                                                                                  
                      According to the Specification, “in the standard prosthesis, [the                       
                contact surface’s centre point] coincides with the centre of articulation                     
                of the prosthesis” (Spec. ¶ 29).  Thus, when a “standard” prosthesis is                       
                                                                                                             
                1 The paragraph numbering refers to the published application,                                
                2004/0153157, published Aug. 5, 2004.                                                         
                                                      2                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013