Ex Parte Muller - Page 3

                Appeal 2007-3992                                                                             
                Application 10/347,867                                                                       
                B. Findings of Fact (FF)                                                                     
                      The following findings of fact and any set out in the Discussion are                   
                supported by a preponderance of the evidence of record.                                      
                      The 867 Application                                                                    
                1. The application on appeal, 10/347,867 ("867 Application"), was filed                      
                22 January 2003.                                                                             
                2. The specification defines a "garniture device" as a "forming device."                     
                (867 Application at ¶ 2, 1:9.)                                                               
                3. The specification defines a "garniture tongue" as a "forming and                          
                compression surface of a compression mold."  (867 Application at ¶ 2, 1:8-                   
                9.)                                                                                          
                4. The subject matter on appeal is most readily comprehended in terms                        
                of Figure 1, from the 867 Application, which has been modified, as                           
                explained below (FF 13):                                                                     









                                                                                                            
                4 Gerhard Hakansson and Guido Quarella, Vorrichtun zum Abstreifen von                        
                Tabakpartikeln von einem Förderer [Apparatus for Stripping off Tobacco                       
                Particles from a Conveyor], EP 0,582,136 A1, published 9 February 1994                       
                (English translation of record provided by the USPTO).                                       
                                                    3                                                        

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013