Republic Plaza Properties Partnership, PFI Republic Limited, Inc., Tax Matters Partner - Page 30

                                       - 30 -                                         

          fact, reasonable based on commercial practice in the Denver                 
          office market, petitioner must nonetheless establish a nontax               
          business purpose for Partnership's granting that rent holiday in            
          order for it to qualify as a reasonable rent holiday described in           
          section 467(b)(5)(C).  It is not clear to us what respondent                
          means by this assertion.                                                    
               If it is respondent's position that petitioner must estab-             
          lish the commercial reasonableness in the Denver office market of           
          not only the duration of the rent holiday at issue, but also the            
          granting of, and the amount of rent reduction during, that rent             
          holiday, we agree.  If it is respondent's position that peti-               
          tioner must establish a nontax business purpose for the granting,           
          the duration, and the amount of the rent holiday at issue other             
          than to conform to commercial practice in the Denver office                 
          market at the time the lease agreement was executed, we disagree.           
          Any such position would be contrary to the concept of, and the              
          reasons for enacting, a "safe harbor" provision like section                
          467(b)(5)(C) and is not supported either by the language of the             
          safe-harbor provision in question (i.e., section 467(b)(5)(C)) or           
          its legislative history.                                                    
               We have found on the record before us that at the time the             
          lease agreement was executed Partnership was aware of, inter                
          alia, the condition of the Denver office market and the practice            
          in that market of offering rent holidays and other lease conces-            





Page:  Previous  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011