Estate of William J. Desmond, Deceased, Donn Kemble, Executor - Page 16




                                       - 16 -                                         

          consideration of all of the evidence in the record, paying                  
          special attention to the presence or absence of the factors                 
          discussed in Rev. Rul. 77-287, 1977-2 C.B. 319.                             
               The following factors favor a high lack of marketability               
          discount:  (1) There was no public market for Deft's stock; (2)             
          Deft's profit margins were below the industry average; (3) all              
          stock in Deft was subject to a restrictive share agreement which            
          provided that a shareholder could transfer his or her stock to a            
          nonshareholder only after the shareholder offered the shares to             
          the remaining shareholders; (4) given the size and low                      
          profitability of Deft, a public offering of the stock was                   
          unlikely in the future; (5) the size of the interest is so large            
          that it may be hard to find potential buyers in the future who              
          could finance such a purchase; and (6) where not already                    
          considered, Deft has large potential environmental liabilities.             
               Only one factor favors a low lack of marketability discount:           
          Deft had an historical favorable distribution policy (it                    
          distributed most of the company's earnings to its shareholders              
          through higher-than-market compensation in the past).                       
               We conclude that a 30-percent lack of marketability discount           
          is appropriate for the Deft stock.  Of this 30-percent discount,            
          10 percent is attributable to Deft's potential environmental                
          liabilities.  We shall apply the 30-percent lack of marketability           
          discount to the unadjusted value we determined under the income             
          method.  We however shall apply only a 20-percent lack of                   
          marketability discount to the unadjusted value we determined                

Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011