David H. and Suzanne Hillman - Page 21




                                       - 21 -                                         
          any reason why petitioners should be prohibited from                        
          recharacterizing the management fees deduction as nonpassive in             
          order to accurately reflect the economic significance of the                
          transaction.  Indeed, respondent does not dispute that                      
          disallowing self-charged treatment for the management fees would            
          result in the very mismatching that Congress sought to alleviate            
          by directing the Secretary to issue regulations for self-charged            
          transactions.  Nor has respondent identified a distinction                  
          between lending and nonlending transactions in the context of               
          this case that would lead us to conclude that the two                       
          transactions should be treated differently under the self-charged           
          regime.                                                                     
               We have considered all other arguments advanced by the                 
          parties, and to the extent we have not addressed these arguments,           
          consider them irrelevant, moot, or without merit.9                          
               To reflect the foregoing,                                              

                                        Decision will be entered for                  
                                   petitioners.                                       






               9 Because of our conclusion that petitioners are entitled to           
          self-charged treatment with respect to the management fees, we              
          find it unnecessary to address their alternative argument that              
          the partnerships properly reported two activities to petitioner             
          (or to the upper tier partnerships or S corporations).                      





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  

Last modified: May 25, 2011