Richard J. and Melodie D. McKeever - Page 46




                                               - 46 -                                                  
            1922).  The elements of personal pleasure are only one factor to                           
            be considered in determining whether the activity is engaged in                            
            for profit.  See sec. 1.183-2(b)(9), Income Tax Regs.                                      
                  In this case, petitioners derived pleasure from their horse                          
            activity and were attached to their horses.  That attachment may                           
            explain why petitioners devoted so little effort to culling their                          
            herd, improving the quality of their horses, and reducing their                            
            operating expenses prior to 1994.                                                          
                  This factor favors respondent’s position.                                            
                  C.  Conclusion                                                                       
                  On balance, we conclude that petitioners’ horse activity                             
            during the years at issue was an activity not engaged in for                               
            profit within the meaning of section 183(c).  In reaching our                              
            decision, we have considered the factors listed in section 1.183-                          
            2(b), Income Tax Regs., all contentions presented by the parties,                          
            and the unique facts and circumstances of this case.                                       
                  Petitioners engaged in their horse activity for at least 11                          
            years, losing more than $500,000 on a cumulative basis.                                    
            Petitioners did not generate a profit or even come close during                            
            any of the years at issue.  Although petitioners were dedicated                            
            to their horses, the totality of the objective facts and                                   
            circumstances does not support petitioners’ assertion that their                           
            horse activity was engaged in for profit.  Petitioners did not                             
            prepare for the economic realities of the business, and they did                           






Page:  Previous  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011