Estate of Cyril I. Magnin, Deceased, Donald Isaac Magnin, Executor - Page 40




                                       - 40 -                                         
                              Joseph’s Percentage  Income  Life       Total           
          Entity     Net Value  Ownership Interest   Benefit Factor   Value           
          JM:                                                                         
          Common    $146,000            27.8%          50%   .35464  $7,197           
          Preferred    69,000           29.5%          50%  .35464   3,609            
          Specialty:                                                                  
          Common    64,000              11.2%          50%   .35464   1,271           
          Preferred    40,000           25.0%          50%   .35464   1,773           
          Total                                             13,850                    
          In adding Cyril’s life interest in control value, $44,296, to the           
          value of the 50-percent life interest received, $13,850, the                
          estate concluded that the total consideration received by Cyril             
          as of October 31, 1951, was $58,146.                                        
                         vi. Value of Remainder Transferred by Cyril                  
               The value of the consideration transferred by Cyril was                
          calculated by applying his ownership interests to the determined            
          common and preferred stock values of JM and Specialty and then              
          deducting his life interest in the companies.  The following                
          chart summarizes Mr. Browning’s calculations:                               
                                    Cyril’s Percentage   Cyril’s Monetary             
          Entity     Net Value      Ownership Interest   Ownership Interest           
          JM:                                                                         
          Common    $146,000            41.1%               $60,000                   
          Preferred    69,000           15.2%          10,500                         
          Specialty:                                                                  
          Common    64,000              4.8%           3,100                          
          Preferred    40,000           25.0%                 10,000                  
          Total                                             83,600                    
          Mr. Browning determined the value of the remainder interest by              
          applying a remainder factor of .50413 to Cyril’s entire stock               
          interest value of $83,600.  Thus, Mr. Browning determined that              






Page:  Previous  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011