John E. Wall - Page 19




                                       - 19 -                                         

          determination of value in her original report.                              
               Ms. Walker was a principal of Willamette Management                    
          Associates, Inc., when she prepared her original report.  She was           
          a principal of Columbia Financial Advisors, Inc., when she                  
          prepared her revised report; she was still a principal of                   
          Columbia at the time of trial.  Respondent stipulated Ms.                   
          Walker’s qualifications and expert status.                                  
               Ms. Walker’s Original Report                                           
               In her original report, Ms. Walker relied almost entirely on           
          the “guideline public company”, or “market-based”, approach to              
          appraise the fair market value of the Demco stock.10  In one                
          variation of this approach, Ms. Walker calculated several                   
          measures of Demco’s historical financial performance; she then              
          used her guideline company data to determine how the public stock           
          markets would have valued a company with those performance                  
          measures.  In the other variation, Ms. Walker applied the                   
          guideline public company data to three measures of Demco’s                  
          projected financial performance for 1992, the year of the gifts.            






               10 Ms. Walker’s original report did include one “income-               
          based” approach, in which Ms. Walker appraised Demco’s value by             
          capitalizing Demco’s distributions to stockholders for 1991 (as             
          adjusted by Ms. Walker).  However, Ms. Walker concluded that this           
          approach deserved very little weight.                                       




Page:  Previous  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011