Herbert C. Haynes, Inc. - Page 21

                                       - 21 -                                         
               A.   Section 447--Method of Accounting for Corporations                
                    Engaged in Farming                                                
               Section 447 provides that taxable income from farming of a             
          corporation engaged in the trade or business of farming “shall              
          be computed on an accrual method of accounting”.  Sec. 447(a).              
          Section 447, however, does not apply to the trade or business of            
          harvesting trees that are not fruit or nut trees.  Id.  We agree            
          with petitioner that section 447 does not require petitioner’s              
          use of the accrual method.                                                  
               We disagree, however, that section 447 “literally,                     
          explicitly, and intentionally” permits petitioner’s use of the              
          cash method under the facts and circumstances presented.                    
          Section 447 sets forth conditions that require use of the                   
          accrual method, not authorization to use the cash method.                   
               B.   Section 448–Whether Petitioner Is a                               
                    “Farming Business”                                                
               Section 448 provides that a C corporation shall not compute            
          its taxable income using the cash method.  Sec. 448(a)(1).  An              
          exception exists for C corporations engaged in a “farming                   
          business.”  Sec. 448(b)(1).  “Farming business” includes “the               
          raising, harvesting, or growing” of timber.  Secs. 448(d)(1)(B),            
          263A(c)(5).  Timber includes “trees raised, harvested, or grown             
          by the taxpayer” other than trees that bear fruit or nuts, and              
          other than trees in a nursery.  Sec. 263A(c)(5), (e)(4).                    
               Petitioner contends that it should be allowed to use the               






Page:  Previous  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011