Ex parte LOO et al. - Page 17




          Appeal No. 95-4714                                                          
          Application No. 08/046,476                                                  



               (f) "cache hit logic means" - internal sequence controller             
          700 in Fig. 8 (col. 22, lines 37-40).                                       
               (g) "cache flush logic means" - the circuitry of Figs. 7               
          and 8.                                                                      
               (h) "a context match flush command comprising a plurality of           
          context identifier bits" - discussed below.                                 
               (I) the cache flush logic means causes flushing if the                 
               protection bit is in a first designated state and if the               
               context bits in the tag array elements match the context               
               bits in the context match flush command - discussed                    
               below.                                                                 
               Regarding the "context" limitations, the examiner contends             
          (Answer at sec. 11g) that                                                   
               Stiffler by necessity must identify which context is                   
               currently active, since context switching is provided for,             
               so Appellant's claimed "context identification registers"              
               [sic, "context identification register" ] is not patentably4                               
               distinguishing, since it is well known in the art for                  
               registers to store identification data.                                
          Even assuming for the sake of argument that the examiner's                  
          reasoning is correct, the only purpose served by such a register            
          would be to keep the MPU apprised of the identity of the context            
          that is currently running.  The examiner has not explained, and             
          it is not apparent to us, why this reasoning would have led the             
          artisan to additionally include context identification bits in              
          the block status register and in the flush command signal, as               


               4See dependent claims 21, 22, 26 and 27.                               
                                       - 17 -                                         





Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007