Ex parte HERMACH - Page 5




          Appeal No. 96-2477                                                          
          Application 08/345,292                                                      


          and single-wing means 10 and 11, comprising the steps of                    
          providing a propulsion module 20 detachably secured to the                  
          fuselage means proximate to inboard ends of the wing means, and             
          detachably attaching the propulsion module to the upper portion             
          of the fuselage means.  Hall is therefore seen as disclosing the            
          subject matter of claim 13 except for the propulsion module being           
          adapted to carry forward and aft engine means.                              
               With respect to independent claim 18, Hall discloses a                 
          method of providing a fixed-wing aircraft with engine propulsion,           
          comprising the steps of forming a propulsion module A having a              
          housing adapted to be juxtaposed to a dry-wing aircraft fuselage            
          B, mounting an aircraft engine 50 having a tractor propeller 51             
          on the propulsion module, and including an engine fuel                      
          compartment 56 within the housing of the propulsion module.                 
          Hence, Hall discloses the subject matter of claim 18 except for             
          mounting on the propulsion module A an aft engine having a pusher           
          propeller aligned with the tractor propeller 51.                            
               In view of the above noted teachings of Henrichsen and                 
          Sanders, the examiner’s conclusion that it would have been                  
          obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art to provide the flight           
          component A of Hall with an aft mounted pusher engine, as called            
          for in the claims, is well taken.  In this regard, in applying              
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007