Ex parte GRAY - Page 9




            Appeal No. 95-0005                                                                           
            Application 08/141,412                                                                       

            not have reasonably suggested a single inductive coupling for                                
            communicating between the interrogator and the transponder.                                  
            In that regard, we have found that White (column 7, lines 23-                                
            28) discloses that inductive coupling may be used to send                                    
            information back and forth between an interrogator and a                                     
            memory system which stores utility measurement data.  But the                                
            examiner did not rely on White for that purpose, and White                                   
            does not disclose that the interrogator sends a clock signal                                 
            to a transponder and that the transponder modulates the                                      
            measurement data over the clock signal for transmission back                                 
            to the interrogator through the same single inductive                                        
            coupling.  The "single inductive coupling" claimed by the                                    
            appellant is more specific than the general inductive coupling                               
            teaching of White.                                                                           


                  In Lapsley, there is a group of signal input lines 35 and                              
            a group of signal output lines 31.  Depending on the state of                                
            the measurement index wheels, different electrical contacts                                  
            are made in the signal path and thus different output lines                                  
            will carry a corresponding output.  It is not seen how such a                                
            system includes a transponder which first "determines" the                                   

                                                   9                                                     





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007