Ex parte CASTONGUAY et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 95-2004                                                          
          Application 07/597,370                                                      

          share the responsibility for handling a collective event load.              
               The examiner answers that the appellants’ claims do not                
          positively recite "working in a cooperative manner."  That is               
          true, but the claims require a plurality of management units                
          to service the event load, and it is recited that the expected              
          event load is allocated among the different management units.               
          Thus, the management units must cooperate at least in that                  
          manner.  The use of a central authority or station to make the              
          individual schedules of many store units whose individual                   
          event loads and personnel resources are separate from each                  
          other does not satisfy the appellants’ claims.                              
               We reject the appellants’ other argument that Fields does              
          not disclose for each store a constantly varying event load by              
          time of day and by the day of week.  In our view, because the               
          tasks to be serviced in each store varies by the time of day                
          and by the day of week, Fields does disclose, for each store                
          unit, a constantly varying event load.                                      
               The examiner relied on AT&T Names to try to account for                
          the "reallocating" step required by the appellants’ claim 13                
          (answer                                                                     



                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007