Ex parte CASTONGUAY et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 95-2004                                                          
          Application 07/597,370                                                      

          at 3-4).  But the deficiency of Fields is not made up by the                
          disclosure of AT&T Names.  While AT&T Names refers to a "team"              
          for handling calls, the appellants correctly argue (Br. at 12)              
          that the team of AT&T Names is not subdivided into a plurality              
          of management units which cooperate to handle a total event                 
          load.  Thus, the allocating step of claim 13 is also lacking                
          in AT&T Names, as it is lacking in Fields.  The system of AT&T              
          Names (at 2-1) forecasts work volume based on historical data,              
          determines how many people are needed to achieve a desired                  
          level of service, and selects the people based on their                     
          availability.  But the examiner has not identified any                      
          disclosure which reasonably would have suggested "allocating                
          the expected event load among the plurality of management                   
          units according to a predetermined number of servers expected               
          to be available at each management unit during each interval                
          of the forecast time period."                                               
               Moreover, claim 13 further requires the step of                        
          reallocating the expected event load among the plurality of                 
          management units during one or more intervals of the forecast               
          time period.  We disagree with the appellants’ contention that              
          AT&T Names does not disclose or reasonably suggest changing                 

                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007