Ex parte VOS - Page 7




          Appeal No. 95-4089                                                          
          Application 08/090,073                                                      

               atoms], although useful as reducing agents too, may be                 
               too strong for delicate hard surface cleanings.                        
               Preferred such dibasic acids are those of the middle                   
               portion of the 2 to 10 carbon atom acid range, succinic                
               [4 carbon atoms], glutaric [5 carbon atoms], adipic [6                 
               carbon atoms] and pimelic acids [7 carbon atoms],                      
               especially the first three thereof, which fortunately are              
               available commercially in mixture.                                     

                    14. The saturated dicarboxylic acids mentioned in                 
          Finding 13 have the general formula:                                        
                                   HOOC)(CH ) )COOH,                                  
                                          2 n                                         
          where n varies from 0 (oxalic acid) to 8 (sebacic acid).                    
          Hence, the formula for glutaric acid [5 carbon atoms] is:                   
                                   HOOC)(CH ) )COOH.                                  
                                          2 3                                         
          See Wertheim, Organic Chemistry, page 249 (2d ed. 1948).                    

                                        Heit                                          
                    15. Heit describes composition which contains maleic              
          acid which are said to be useful for removing scale from the                
          jacket side of a glass-lined jacketed equipment (col. 1,                    
          lines 13-14).  "Scale" includes "mineral and organic solids"                
          deposited on glass surfaces from contact with water (col. 1,                
          lines 21-23).                                                               

                                        - 7 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007