Ex parte SITES et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 96-4033                                                          
          Application No. 08/086,354                                                  


                    In their reply brief, appellants argue that at col. 1,            
          lines 46-55, Lee neither describes nor suggests “means for testing          
          a register defined in said branch instruction to determine a                
          condition specified in said opcode, after said means for fetching           
          has started fetching said next instruction…” as recited in claim            
          11.                                                                         
                    Appellants do not contend that Lee does not teach the             
          first and second elements of claim 11, and we are convinced that            
          these elements are in fact disclosed by the reference.                      
                    With respect to the third element of claim 11 defining            
          means for fetching a next instruction or, in the alternative, a             
          branch target instruction, this subject matter is taught by Lee at          
          column 1, lines 6-15, wherein it is disclosed that the decision to          
          branch or not to branch may be based on one or more events which            
          include positive and negative numbers.  In their reply brief,               
          appellants have not challenged the examiner’s position at page 3            
          of the answer to the effect that this disclosure satisfies the              
          third element of the claim.                                                 
                    Regarding the fourth element of claim 11, at page 4,              
          lines 11-21, appellants do not contend that Lee does not teach              
          means for testing a register identified in a branch instruction to          
                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007