MORRISON et al. V. MANNHEIMER et al. - Page 64




          Interference No. 103,197                                                      


               Morrison described the experiment, the researcher's                      
               finger pulse creates a pulsatile motion artifact.  In the                
               absence of noise, i.e., when Dr. Morrison happened to                    
               keep the needles so steady that only his finger pulse was                
               taken up, he happened to create an acceptable signal.                    
          Specifically, this finger pulse caused variations in the                      
          spacing of the needle tips:101                                                
               [I]t is obvious that the pulse he detected was his own                   
               pulse, but the origin was not the arterial blood moving                  
               in an out (= arterial pulse) but a motion artifact, i.e.                 
               a changing distance between two fiber tips creating a                    
               changing pulse length through tissue with all the                        
               components present, tissue, venous blood, capillary                      
               blood, arterial blood while only the arterial blood                      
               should change (optical plethysmography).                                 
          This argument has support in the following test conducted by                  
          Falkowski, which he offered in support of the  argument,                      
          discussed infra, that a needle spacing of 1 or 2mm of tissue                  
          is too close to provide a detectable modulation signal even                   
          under optimal coupling conditions, i.e., without using optical                
          fibers.                                                                       
          Although Falkowski does not so state, Morrison  appears to102                            
          accept Buschmann's claim  that this test was performed on a103                                                  


            BR 31, ¶ 11.101                                                                      
            Morr.Open.Br. 37.102                                                                      
            B.Br. 75; Buschmann, BR 19, ¶ 27.103                                                                      
                                        - 61 -                                          





Page:  Previous  57  58  59  60  61  62  63  64  65  66  67  68  69  70  71  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007