Ex parte FOGAL - Page 7




            Appeal No. 2000-0949                                                                              
            Application No. 08/721,505                                                                        



              providing a semiconductor leadframe strip Holdgrafer teaches the use of the vision              
              having a plurality of die mounting sites, system for use with dies with a leadframe             
              each mounting site having an associated strip with associated lead fingers having               
              arrangement of lead fingers including tip tip portions as shown in figures 1-3.                 
              portions;                                                                                       
              attaching the die to the leadframe strip at a Inherent in the production of the chip would      
              mounting site;                            have been the connection of the die to the            
                                                        substrate bearing the leadframe strip.                
                                                        Alternatively, it would have been obvious to          
                                                        one of ordinary skill in the art to have              
                                                        connected the two bodies together prior to            
                                                        performing wire bonding.                              
              bonding a fine bond wire to a bond pad of Since the vision system of Holdgrafer is              
              the die;                                  intended to be associated with a wire                 
                                                        bonding apparatus, the wire bonding                   
                                                        apparatus would bond the wire to the die.             
                                                        (See col. 7, lines 19-32)                             
              determining a width (W) and a longitudinal Holdgrafer discloses the use of                      
              axis of the tip portion of a selected leaddetermining the width of the lead finger              
              finger;                                   and dividing this width by 2 to determine             
                                                        the center.  (See col.5, lines 29- col. 6,            
                                                        lines 22.)  Holdgrafer does not specifically          
                                                        disclose the determination of the                     
                                                        longitudinal axis.  In our view, it would have        
                                                        been obvious to a skilled artisan to have             
                                                        the vision system similarly determine the             
                                                        longitudinal axis and use it for tracking the         
                                                        bonding tool.  As evidence to support this            
                                                        position, we rely upon appellant’s own                
                                                        discussion in the “Background of the                  
                                                        Invention” section.                                   






                                                      7                                                       





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007