Ex parte CLINE - Page 15




          Appeal No. 1997-2247                                      Page 15           
          Application No. 08/259,798                                                  


          of precharging bit lines BL and BL* to high or low logic                    
          states."  Col. 5, ll. 24-26.  Precharging to the low logic                  
          state necessarily requires disabling the high logic                         
          precharging voltage and supplying an alternative low logic                  
          voltage.                                                                    


               We are persuaded that these teachings would have                       
          suggested the limitations of "a precharge disabling circuit,                
          responsive to a control signal, for disabling the precharge                 
          circuit from applying the common precharge voltage and for                  
          concurrently supplying an alternative common voltage to both                
          leads of each of the plurality of pairs of bitlines" and "a                 
          circuit arranged for simultaneously precharging both leads of               
          each of the plurality of pairs of bitlines to a common                      
          precharge voltage and, in response to a control signal,                     
          supplying concurrently an alternative common voltage to both                
          leads of each of the plurality of pairs of bitlines."                       
          Therefore, we affirm the rejection of claims 10 and 11 as                   
          obvious over Kuo.  Our affirmance is based only on the                      
          arguments made in the briefs.  Arguments not made therein are               
          not before us, are not at issue, and are considered waived.                 







Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007