Ex parte BOUTARD et al. - Page 9




          Appeal No. 1998-0049                                                         
          Application 08/289,028                                                       

          Vandierendonck uses a mask field for selecting display                       
          segments during a register instruction, but not for                          
          conditional execution of an instruction (RBr2).                              
               We agree with Appellants' findings regarding the                        
          teachings of Vandierendonck as applied by the Examiner.                      
          While figure 5 of Vandierendonck discloses mask bits, these                  
          mask bits are only used for the flag and register                            
          instructions, not the jump instructions.  The mask bits in                   
          the flag and register instructions are not used to select                    
          any of the conditions in the condition logic 40, but are                     
          used to produce constants in the digit mask logic 35 for use                 
          in connection with the sequentially addressed memory                         
          (SAM) 20 (col. 13, line 12 to col. 14, line 9).  The                         
          Examiner's response, quoted supra, fails to distinguish                      
          between the conditional branch instructions, which do not                    
          have mask bits but are responsive to status conditions, and                  
          the flag/register instructions, which do have mask bits but                  
          are not responsive to status conditions.  Accordingly, the                   
          Examiner's rationale is erroneous.                                           
               However, it appears that claim 61 is anticipated by                     
          Vandierendonck when the bits of the "class field," I9 and                    

                                        - 9 -                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007