Ex parte DUFF - Page 10




          Appeal No. 1998-0073                                                        
          Application 08/273,813                                                      

          external port nor a form-fitted cover for the port.  Hsieh                  
          clearly teaches a clam shell configuration in col. 3, lines 15              
          through 27 and Fig. 2 and hinges are shown at the location                  
          where the cover is attached to the bottom housing and where a               
          battery pack is attached to its back.  Hsieh in col. 5, lines               
          23 through 27 further discloses external ports in the bottom                
          housing for connection with peripheral devices.  Chadima in                 
          col. 14, lines 8 through 14 teaches the connection of                       
          connectors 93 and 94 via the end cap 95 to the housing where                
          an O-ring 106 which is usually made of rubber and a gasket 109              
          seal the external ports 108.  Chadima in col. 14, lines 20                  
          through 23 indicates that the completion of the above assembly              
          seals off the data terminal from the environment.  We conclude              
          that Hsieh teaches the clam shell portable computer with an                 
          external port in the bottom housing while Chadima’s end cap                 
          95, O-ring 106, and gasket 109 together form a “port sealing                
          unit” which seals the external ports 108.                                   
               Chadima is concerned with sealing the housing of a                     
          portable computer and sealing off the external ports from the               
          outside environment such as dust and moisture.  In particular,              
          Chadima in col. 3, lines 1 through 9 discloses:                             

                                         10                                           





Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007