Appeal No. 1999-0485 Application 08/526,781 operation means to n-bit length in accordance with a rounding signal provided by said instruction means, said rounding processing means not rounding the output of said shifting operation means when the arithmetic instruction is indicative of a logical operation and rounding the output of said shifting operation means when the arithmetic instruction is indicative of an arithmetic operation. We note that Appellant’s claim 13 recites a rounding unit, coupled to said shifter, for rounding the shift data when said arithmetic operator provides resultant data based on an arithmetic operation and for not rounding the shift data when said arithmetic operator provides resultant data based on a logical operation. Finally, we note that Appellant’s claim 25 recites method step d) rounding the shift data when the resultant data is provided based on an arithmetic operation and not rounding the shift data when the resultant data is provided based on a logical operation. Thus, we find that all the independent claims require a rounding process which selectively rounds based on an arithmetic operation or selectively does not round based upon a logical operation. On pages 4 and 5 of the answer, the Examiner acknowledges 8Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007