VISSER et al v. HOFVANDER et al - Page 41




          Interference 103,579                                                        

          the phrases in Claims 23 and 24 of Visser’s involved application.           
               Visser’s dependent Claim 14 limits the base sequence for               
          transcription in the construct utilized in Visser’s method                  
          Claim 1 to “a sequence of bases complementary to the sequence as            
          set forth in Figure 3" (Visser’s Claim 14), but it does not                 
          define “a full length potato . . . GBSS . . . cDNA or genomic DNA           
          sequence . . . in reverse orientation” of Visser’s Claim 24.                
          Accordingly, we look to the specification of Visser’s involved              
          application for clarification.                                              
               The Summary of the Invention in Visser’s involved                      
          application (VR 148, l. 1-16) refers to “at least one gene                  
          construct containing a potato granule-bound starch synthase                 
          (PGBSS) cDNA or genomic DNA sequence in reverse or functional               
          orientation . . . giving rise to tubers containing essentially              
          amylose-free starch” (VR 148, l. 3-8).  There, the GBSS cDNA                
          or genomic DNA sequence is limited by its antisense function, but           
          it is not otherwise structurally defined so to enable us to                 
          compare it to any of Hofvander’s SEQ ID Nos. 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5.              
          Visser’s involved application acknowledges (VR 149, l. 6-11):               
                    The sense or anti-sense PGBSS cDNA or genomic DNA                 
               sequence does not have to cover the complete coding                    
               sequence but should cover a sufficient part of it to be                
               effective for obtaining tubers containing essentially                  
               amylose-free starch.                                                   
               Visser’s involved application describes the construction               

                                        -41-                                          





Page:  Previous  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007