VISSER et al v. HOFVANDER et al - Page 42




          Interference 103,579                                                        
          of the pGB50 (antisense) and pGB60 (sense) GBSS vectors depicted            
          in its Figure 1 (VR 182) as follows (VR 149, l. 17-26):                     
               The original GBSS cDNA which contained an internal EcoRI               
               site was subcloned as two fragments in pUC9, denoted                   
               pWx 1.1 and pWx 1.3.  The 1.3 kb GBSS cDNA fragment from               
               pWx 1.3 was ligated into the partial EcoRI-restricted                  
               plasmid pWx 1.1 yielding pGB2.  Plasmid pGB2 was restricted            
               with SpeI, made blunt ended with Klenow enzyme, BamHI.                 
               The GBSS cDNA fragment was ligated into BamHI-restricted               
               pUC18 yielding pGB6 and into BamHI-digested calf intestinal            
               phosphatase (CIP) treated pROK-1 yielding pGB50 (antisense)            
               and pGB60 (sense).                                                     
          The antisense (pGB50) and sense (pGB60) were the vectors                    
          purportedly used to transform potato plants (VR 154) and                    
          substantially inhibit the expression of PGBSS therein                       
          (VR 156-158).                                                               
               We consider now the prosecution history of Visser’s involved           
          application and other evidence.  Since Visser’s 1989 publication            
          (Appendix A) is cited for its background and comparable                     
          description in Visser’s involved application (VR 143, 151, 152,             
          and 170), we look first to its disclosure.  Visser’s 1989                   
          publication teaches (Appendix A, p. 187, col. 1; citations                  
          omitted):                                                                   
                    The potato GBSS cDNA was isolated from a cDNA                     
               library established from . . . potato tubers . . . .                   
               Subcloning of the cDNA in plasmid pUC9 yielded plasmids                
               pWx 1.1 (5'-end of the potato GBSS cDNA[)], and pWx 1.3                
               (3'-end of the potato cDNA) and pGB6 (pUC18 with the                   
               two EcoRI cDNA fragments from pWx 1.1 and pWx 1.3).                    
               . . . .                                                                
          Visser’s 1989 publication explains that the ligated 2.4-kb insert           
                                        -42-                                          





Page:  Previous  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007