VISSER et al v. HOFVANDER et al - Page 95




          Interference 103,579                                                        
          of the GBSS gene, i.e., it is not a fragment of Visser’s full               
          length cDNA or genomic DNA sequence coding for GBSS.  According             
          to Visser, the evidence of record shows that Hergersberg’s 275 bp           
          cDNA overlaps Hofvander’s 342 bp SEQ ID No. 1, i.e., it is cDNA             
          corresponding to a genomic DNA fragment of the GBSS gene found              
          for the most part inside the promoter region and outside the                
          coding region of the GBSS gene.  Hergersberg’s 275 bp cDNA                  
          sequence is not encompassed by either Visser’s full length cDNA             
          or genomic DNA sequence coding for GBSS.  According to Visser,              
          the evidence of record also shows that Hergersberg’s 500/800 bp             
          cDNA fragment in the antisense direction is fully encompassed by            
          Hofvander’s 2549 bp SEQ ID 2 in the antisense direction and that            
          both Hergersberg’s 500/800 bp fragment and Hofvander’s 2549 bp              
          SEQ ID 2 in the antisense direction are fully encompassed either            
          by Visser’s full length cDNA or genomic DNA sequence coding for             
          GBSS in the antisense direction.  It reasonably would appear from           
          the above that if Hofvander’s genomic 342 bp SEQ ID No. 1 in the            
          antisense direction would have been prima facie obvious to                  
          persons having ordinary skill in the art in view of Hergersberg’s           
          construct comprising its 275 bp cDNA fragment in the antisense              
          direction, which overlaps Hofvander’s genomic 342 bp SEQ ID No. 1           
          in the antisense direction, and if Hofvander’s genomic 2549 bp              
          SEQ ID No. 2 in the antisense direction would have been prima               
          facie obvious to persons having ordinary skill in the art in view           
                                        -95-                                          





Page:  Previous  88  89  90  91  92  93  94  95  96  97  98  99  100  101  102  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007