Ex Parte KIM - Page 9




              Appeal No. 2001-2579                                                                  Page 9                 
              Application No. 08/885,996                                                                                   


              step S13 is followed by step S16 to find out the print driver or drivers in the hard disk,                   
              which is/are compatible with or applicable to the language interpreter or interpreters                       
              represented by the received interpreter-identification data."  Id. at ll. 44-50.                             


                     Third, the examiner asserts, "Sasaki teaches . . . generating print data                              
              corresponding to the confirmed data processing form of the printer (Col. 6, lines 50-53).                    
              . . ."  (Examiner's Answer at 2-3.)  The appellant argues, "Sasaki's language                                
              interpreters do not generate print data corresponding to a confirmed data processing                         
              form of the printer, but instead interpret commands from the computer to the printer to                      
              tell the printer how to format (font size, graphics, compression of data sent to the                         
              printer, color, etc.) the document being printed."  (Reply Br. at 9.)                                        


                     Claim 1 specifies in pertinent part the following limitations: "generating print data                 
              corresponding to the confirmed data processing form of said printer. . . ."  Giving the                      
              representative claim its broadest, reasonable construction, the limitations require                          
              generating print data corresponding to the printer's form of data processing.                                


                     Turning to Sasaki, we find that the reference's PC, after confirming its printer's                    
              form of language (as explained regarding the second point of contention), generates                          
              print data corresponding to the form.  Specifically, after storing the aforementioned print                  








Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007