Ex Parte KIM - Page 10




              Appeal No. 2001-2579                                                                 Page 10                 
              Application No. 08/885,996                                                                                   


              driver in its RAM, the PC uses the print driver "for preparing print data by conversion in                   
              a language that can be interpreted by the . . . the laser printer LP. . . ."  Col. 6, ll. 51-53.             
              Therefore, we affirm the rejection of claim 1 and of claim 2, which falls therewith.                         


                                                         Claim 3                                                           
                     Rather than reiterate the positions of the examiner or the appellant in toto, we                      
              address the main point of contention therebetween.  The examiner asserts, "[i]t would                        
              have been obvious . . ., in view of Applicant's admitted prior art, to have modified the                     
              printing system of the combination of Sasaki and Kageyama et al. for the data                                
              processing form comprising one of a byte form, a word form, and a long word form, and                        
              if the data processing form comprises the word form (two bytes), then the data                               
              processing form comprises one of a high order type and a low order type. . . ."                              
              (Examiner's Answer at 4.)  "[A]dmit[ting] that byte forms, word forms and long word                          
              forms of data processing in a printer are well known," (Reply Br. at 11), the appellant                      
              argues, "the applied art fails to teach confirming a data processing form, wherein said                      
              data processing form comprising one of a byte form, a word form, and a long word                             
              form, and if said data processing form comprises said word form, then said data                              
              processing form comprises one of a high order type and a low order type. . . ."  (Id.)                       











Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007